In Pakistan’s hierarchical judicial system, the right to challenge a lower court’s decision forms the cornerstone of appellate justice; a constitutional safeguard ensuring that errors can be corrected and justice refined through review. Whether you’re a litigant dissatisfied with a civil decree, a defendant convicted in a criminal trial, or a party aggrieved by a revenue or administrative order, understanding the appellate process is crucial. This comprehensive guide demystifies the journey from a lower court’s verdict to a higher court’s review in Pakistan.

Understanding the Judicial Hierarchy

Pakistan’s court structure is pyramidal:

1. Supreme Court of Pakistan (Highest court, Constitutional jurisdiction)

2. High Courts (Provincial appellate courts)

3. District & Sessions Courts (Principal trial courts)

4. Civil Courts/Criminal Courts (Specialized lower courts)

5. Special Tribunals & Authorities (Revenue, Services, etc.)

The appellate path typically moves upward through these tiers, though specific routes vary by case type.

When Can You Appeal? Grounds for Challenge

Not every unfavorable judgment can be appealed. Valid grounds include:

Substantial Legal Errors:

• Misinterpretation or misapplication of law

• Failure to consider relevant evidence

• Consideration of irrelevant or inadmissible evidence

• Violation of procedural safeguards

Jurisdictional Issues:

• Court exercised jurisdiction it didn’t possess

• Court failed to exercise jurisdiction it did possess

Manifest Injustice:

• Decisions contrary to the weight of evidence

• Excessive or inadequate sentences (criminal cases)

• Unconscionable decrees (civil cases)

Procedural Irregularities:

• Denial of fair hearing opportunity

• Bias or reasonable apprehension of bias

• Violation of natural justice principles

The Appellate Journey: Step-by-Step Process

STAGE 1: POST-JUDGMENT PROCEDURES IN THE TRIAL COURT

1. Obtain Certified Copies of Judgment & Decree

• Immediately after judgment, apply for certified copies

• Essential for drafting appeals and calculating limitation periods

• Fee: Varies by court (typically PKR 100-500 per page)

2. Calculate Limitation Period Carefully

Different appeals have different strict deadlines:

• Civil Appeals: Generally 30 days from judgment/order date*

• Criminal Appeals: 30 days from conviction/sentence date*

• Revenue Appeals: Varies by statute (often 90 days)

• Constitutional Petitions: No strict limitation but “without undue delay”

*Days counted excluding the day of judgment and including the last day, unless it’s a court holiday.

3. File Application for Stay of Proceedings (If Urgent)

• If immediate harm is likely (property transfer, demolition, etc.)

• File under Order XXXIX Rule 1 & 2 CPC (civil) or relevant criminal provisions

• Requires demonstrating “irreparable loss” if stay not granted

STAGE 2: PREPARING & FILING THE APPEAL

4. Draft the Memorandum of Appeal

This critical document must contain:

• Case title with appellant/respondent details

• Judgment details being challenged

• Grounds of appeal (numbered consecutively)

• Prayer/Relief sought

• Legal provisions under which appeal is filed

Technical Requirement: Must be signed by appellant or authorized pleader

5. Arrange Necessary Documents

• Certified judgment/order copies

• Trial court evidence (exhibits list, important documents)

• Power of Attorney (if represented by lawyer)

• Court fee calculation and payment proof

• Index of documents

6. Pay Court Fees

Calculated based on:

• Nature of case (civil, criminal, revenue)

• Value of suit (for money appeals)

• Prescribed schedules in Court Fees Act 1870

Example: For civil appeals, typically 1/3 of original suit’s court fee

7. File in Appropriate Appellate Court

• From Civil Judge to District Judge (regular civil appeals)

• From Magistrate to Sessions Judge (criminal appeals)

• From Civil/Criminal courts to High Court (when statute permits direct appeal)

• From Tribunals to High Courts (administrative/service matters)

Filing Method: Through court clerk with triplicate copies (one for court, one for opposite party, one for your record)

STAGE 3: POST-FILING PROCEDURES

8. Service of Notice to Respondent

• Court issues notice to respondents after admission

• Respondent files reply/cross-objections (if any)

• Time period: Usually 15-30 days for response

9. Record Summoning & Perusal

• Appellate court summons trial court record

• Both parties can request inspection

• Critical for identifying gaps in trial record

10. Hearing & Arguments

• Admission Hearing: Preliminary hearing to determine if appeal raises arguable points

• Regular Hearing: Detailed arguments on merits

• Time Allocation: Varies by court complexity (days to months)

11. Judgment & Decree

• Appellate court may:

  • Uphold lower court decision

  • Modify the decision

  • Overturn/reverse the decision

  • Remand case back to trial court

• Decree prepared and signed

• Certified copies available within 15-30 days

Special Appeal Mechanisms

Civil Revisional Jurisdiction (Section 115 CPC)

• Not an appeal but “revision”

• Available when no regular appeal lies

• Only for jurisdictional errors or illegal exercise of jurisdiction

• Filed directly to High Court

Constitutional Jurisdiction (Article 199)

• When fundamental rights violated or jurisdictional issues arise

• Filed directly in High Court

• Discretionary remedy—not automatic right

Leave to Appeal to Supreme Court (Article 185)

• From High Court to Supreme Court

• Requires “leave” (permission) granted only for:

  • Substantial constitutional interpretation

  • Public importance matters

  • Exceptional circumstances

Critical Considerations & Strategic Insights

1. The “Substantial Question of Law” Barrier

For second appeals (High Court), Pakistan follows the “substantial question of law” requirement under Section 100 CPC. Pure factual re-evaluations are generally not entertained. Your appeal must frame legal questions like:

• “Whether the trial court misapplied Section 9 of the Contract Act 1872…”

• “Whether the evidence was admissible under Qanun-e-Shahadat…”

2. Interim Relief Strategies

• Stay Orders: File immediately to suspend judgment operation

• Injunction Applications: Prevent irreversible actions during appeal

• Security/Guarantee Offers: In money decrees, sometimes offering bank guarantee can stay execution

3. The Record’s Centrality

Appellate courts heavily rely on trial court records. Ensure:

• All evidence properly exhibited at trial

• Objections recorded during evidence recording

• Clear, readable transcribed witness statements

4. Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) Window

Many appellate courts now refer cases to mediation/conciliation first. Consider if settlement is possible before investing in full appeal.

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

Limitation Lapses

• Calculating from wrong date (date of judgment vs. date of knowledge)

• Missing exclusion of court holidays

• Not accounting for time obtaining certified copies

Procedural Defaults

• Incomplete court fee payment

• Incorrect appellate forum selection

• Defective power of attorney

• Failure to serve notices properly

Substantive Weaknesses

• Appealing only on factual disagreements without legal grounds

• Poorly drafted grounds (vague, argumentative, multiple in one ground)

• Not addressing all adverse findings of trial court

Cost & Time Realities

Financial Implications:

• Court fees: Variable based on case value

• Lawyer fees: Typically 30-50% of trial fees for each appellate stage

• Miscellaneous: Transcription, certification, process service costs

Time Expectations:

• District Court Appeals: 1-3 years for disposal

• High Court Appeals: 2-5 years typically

• Supreme Court Appeals: 3+ years

Note: Time varies significantly by case complexity, court backlog, and procedural efficiency.

Legal Aid & Pro Bono Options

For those unable to afford appeals:

• Provincial Legal Aid Authorities: Free legal assistance for qualified individuals

• Law College Clinics: Law universities often provide assistance

• NGO Initiatives: Organizations like AGHS, SPARC offer support in specific matters

Digital Transformation: E-Courts & E-Filing

Pakistan’s judiciary is gradually implementing e-courts:

• Case status tracking online

• Limited e-filing in some High Court branches

• Online cause lists

• Judgment databases (Pakistan Law Site, PLD)

Check your relevant court’s website for digital options that might expedite processes.

Conclusion: The Appellate Path as Constitutional Right

Challenging a lower court decision in Pakistan is neither simple nor swift, but it remains a fundamental right enshrined in Articles 4, 9, and 25 of the Constitution. Success requires meticulous attention to procedural details, strategic framing of legal questions, and patience through lengthy processes.

As Justice Rustam Kayani famously observed, “The right to appeal is not mere procedure; it is the breathing space of justice.” Whether your case involves property rights, personal liberty, contractual obligations, or constitutional freedoms, navigating the appellate process effectively requires understanding that each rung of the judicial ladder serves not to re-try your case, but to review whether justice was done according to law.

Before embarking on this journey, consult with experienced counsel to assess not just whether you can appeal, but whether you should—weighing the costs, time, and likelihood of meaningful relief against the finality that even an unfavorable judgment can bring.

Visit: https://sohaibnsultan.pk